Stringer: N.Y. City's MTA Burden Too Big

stringer-scott.jpg

New York City taxpayers and businesses contribute more than $10.1 billion annually in taxes, fares, tolls and direct expenditures toward Metropolitan Transportation Authority operations — far higher than generally recognized — according to city Comptroller Scott Stringer.

"When it comes to paying for the MTA, New York City residents and businesses bear a much larger financial burden than we ever knew before," Stringer said May 27.

In addition to the $5.3 billion city residents paid in fares and tolls, according to Stringer, New Yorkers paid $4.8 billion in taxes, subsidies and direct expenditures to the MTA last year.

"That's the equivalent of every New York City household contributing $130 per month to the MTA's coffers before they step onto the subway platform or pay a toll. It may be an 'invisible' fare, but New York City's taxpayers feel it in their wallet every month," he said.

Stringer examined the full cost of the MTA to New York City, commuter counties within the MTA region, New York State, Connecticut and New Jersey, including operating expenditures, direct expenditures by the city on behalf of the MTA, and capital expenditures.

The "invisible fare" also includes $612.5 million in direct expenditures that pay for policing New York City Transit and debt service payments, said Stringer.

Though the MTA is a state agency, the state's contributions to the MTA have been significantly less than the city's. In MTA's fiscal year 2014, New York State paid $603.5 million to the MTA, roughly 4% of the authority's operating budget. This figure is 1/8th of the amount that the city contributes to the MTA, excluding fares and tolls, said Stringer.

MTA Chairman Thomas Prendergast in early May asked city officials to contribute $300 million per year to the 2015-2019 capital program, or triple what the city now contributes. He also wants an additional $1 billion for the long-delayed Second Avenue subway line over the five years of the plan.

The MTA's proposed $32 billion capital program has a $15 billion shortfall.

For reprint and licensing requests for this article, click here.
Transportation industry New York
MORE FROM BOND BUYER